Here at First We Feast, we love a good scandal, and in lieu of the recent Oreo outrage over the lack of double stuff in the brand’s beloved “Double-Stuf” cookies, we thought it apt to compile a list of the most egregious cases of false advertising food has ever seen. Don’t be fooled by what the big corporate food man tells you—do you still think all Subway Footlongs are 12 inches, Kashi is “All Natural”, and Whole Foods doesn’t sell genetically modified foods? Think again.

Click through the gallery to see the false food advertising scandals that rocked both the food world and consumers’ minds.