Comedian Amy Sedaris, known for her role on Strangers with Candy, her brother, and her book, I Like You: Hospitality Under the Influence, has returned to bring us a recipe for cat litter and turds. For her current comedy series, The Heart, She Holler, Sedaris was forced to eat kitty litter for your viewing pleasure. She and the set designer concocted a recipe for edible cat litter made from walnuts, cocoa, and 100 Grand bars. Sounds kind of tempting, doesn’t it?

On a recent episode of Late Night with Jimmy Fallon, Sedaris was kind enough to give Fallon a taste. The Heart, She Holler is currently beginning its second season on Cartoon Network’s Adult Swim.

Watch the video to witness Fallon’s face when he bites into that first cat turd. You never forget your first time.

[via Eater]