Sure, you’ve grown accustomed to ordering your go-to lazy dinner online. But has your body ever reveled in the aftermath of an extra-large pizza order? Ours hasn’t either. It’s time to ditch the red-and-white cardboard boxes for some homemade flavor. By choosing your own toppings, you get to decide exactly how pizza night goes down. Here are 10 homemade pizzas that will make you question the next time you think about ordering in.

Click through the gallery above to see all of the recipes.